The Trump Administration will seek modest changes to the North American Free Trade Agreement renegotiation process. According to a draft of a letter sent to Congress last week, the Administration is seeking a more conventional approach to trade negotiation.
NAFTA, which was established in 1994 between Canada, the U.S., and Mexico, aims to reduce trading costs, increase multilateral investment, while helping North America become more competitive.However, during the 2016 presidential campaign, President Trump made the debate over free trade one of the central topics of his campaign.
What is the plan for the renegotiation?
The persistent U.S. deficit in goods trade with Canada and Mexico demands that the administration take quick action to revise the relationship and adapt to the new global environment. In 2016, the U.S. deficit in goods with Canada is $42.848 billion (Data from Census.gov.foreign-trade/balance), which is only 2% of the total Canadian trade of $545 billion.
The trade deficit in goods with Mexico is $63.191 billion. Exports are $231 billion, made up primarily of auto parts and petroleum products, while imports are $294 billion, with cars, trucks, and auto parts being the largest components.
In addition, this administration believes that Mexico has taken millions of manufacturing jobs from the U.S. Should the U.S. or Mexico just leave NAFTA?
My short answer is NO. According to the data provided by Mexican government, more than 80% of Mexican goods exports are tax free to the United States, and since the signing of the trade agreement, all kinds of US companies in Mexico have grown with large number of jobs.
In the United States, some U.S. manufacturers get hurt because of NAFTA, while most American farmers profit from the agreement. Withdrawing from NAFTA will aggravate the U.S. goods trade deficit and tensions will continue to escalate, and eventually this will lead to the rupture of NAFTA.
Mexican cars will be more competitive in the United States due to depreciation of the peso, and the trade deficit will expand. On the other hand, Mexico is the third largest agricultural export market for the United States and U.S. exports of agricultural products will be more expensive for Mexican consumers.
As President Trump moves to revisit the North American Free Trade Agreement with Mexico and Canada, some are concerned these negotiations would actually limit the aggregate benefits the United States can gain. Some even claim that the United States may be handing a leadership role to China, a country that has repeatedly ignored intellectual property laws and manipulates its own currency.
Handing this role to a country who’s bad practices are at the helm of whats wrong with global economy could make for a trying situation, and one that President Trump should think about before passing the torch to China.